Review Submitted By:
Started on Shadow Siege
: August 2004
Jan 16, 2005
TMC Listing: Shadow Siege
The following review is the opinion of the review's author [Chris]
and in no way represents the opinions of this website or its staff.
The first thing to note is that Shadowsiege is not for the casual
MU*er. It is an RP enforced MUD (Though in a lot of ways, it more
resembles a MUSH), and RP is taken very seriously.
The system is class-less and level-less. It's done very well, leaving
your character openended. Character advancement is gained solely
through roleplaying. The code rewards characters based on the quality
of their 'emotes' automatically once every hour. One gains little or
nothing from combat with NPCs and Mobiles.
The playerbase is very friendly and helpful, as are the admin. There
are a handfull of Player Aids to help newbies get acclimated to the
environment. The players themselves often go to lengths to help get a
new character involved in the game and whatever is going on.
The game itself is fairly stable, and does not crash too often. This
is surprising since the game is still in 'beta.' Reboots are made for
putting in new code and such.
The admin maintain a very active role in the game and the goings-on of
the characters in their game. They enjoy playing as much as anyone
else, so this just makes it even moreso.
Occasional admin-run RP events will happen as well. Sometimes they
seem very carefully planned and thought out. Other times, they seem
more winged and 'spur of the moment.' When these events work out well,
it can make the players feel like their character is an integral part
of the game world and contributing meaningfully to the overall story.
While much has been done with the venerable Circle 3.0 codebase
(renamed to Draig), you can still sense its limitations lurking in the
background. Considering the scope of what Shadowsiege tries to
accomplish, Circle seems a poor choice. It creates a stark contrast to
the beautiful and dynamic RP in the game by leaving a lot of things
feeling too static. This can sometimes lead to a little bit of
frustration if one is used to MUSH, MOO, or LP style play.